28 feb 2009

Luna rambles: how long does a meeting last?*

[[* I have received unhappy feedback on this article, saying that this is a gross generalization that doesn't tackle the real problems of Spanish University. I agree with that judgement: this is not an academic article but a blog entry in which I talk about my personal experience. The target of this criticism is not the figure of "the" Professor, but a specific kind of Prof that I met at the UCM; there are many good profs in Spain who deserve recognition. If you are reading this, it's because you're not one of the bad guys!!]]

--

For the sake of entertainment and enlightenment, these days I have been thinking of some differences between the way people do things "here" and "there" -- meaning, in Spain and Canada. And of course there are many: the way one makes friends and relate to others of the same and different sex, younger and older; food issues (will I survive as a vegetarian in this country?), etc. But I'm particularly fascinated by what it means to be a young, female, skilled researcher in Spain. It makes me happy to know I'll return to Canada next year.

In my experience, doing research "here" is much harder, often an excruciating experience. There is some kind of ... fetishism of (male) authority, maybe? Obsession with professional rankings? A socially-established need to step on the necks of others who are perceived to be below oneself? Whatever the case, the result is that I never seem to be placed in a position of equality regarding the people that I work with, and who most of the time happen to be white-headed males in positions of authority within the university, who think that just because they got a permanent position when the first democratic government decided to pump money into public education in the 1980s, and thus have been "there" for several decades, have the right to do what they want, whenever they want, with no regard to the army of "us" that they perceive to be at their orders. Hell, no. If you ask me, this country's university would be much better off were these guys [note: a specific kind of prof] working elsewhere, or made responsible for what they (don't) do.

[section cut due to several complaints]

Once I was at a meeting to plan a research project for which we had gotten government money. The meeting was planned to last from 10 am to 8 pm (!!!). The director of the project didn't show up. The co-director showed up 6 hours late (I should say that he called to say he'd be 15 minutes late). The rest of us worked at neck-breaking pace, sitting down next door to the office of a prof who years before had given me a bad grade because I refused to have sex with him -- he's still there making big money and doing the same thing to other students, despite the fact that I talked to every single person in charge at school. And by the time the co-director came, the work was almost ready for the plucking.

So the other day, when another prof at another university asked me if I didn't have a sense of responsibility towards a country, a state, that had granted me the privilege of a public education, I said yes, I do. I certainly do. But do you know what it is to be a young, female researcher and being treated with respect? Do you know what it means to be independent, not having to obey, or submit to other person's whims, while you do your work? Do you know how long a meeting lasts when I meet with my boss in Canada, and that he's always there?

When you can give me the possibility to come back as what I am to do what I wanna do and live off it, give me a call. In the meanwhile, clean your kitchen before telling me mine's dirty. I'll be singing Oh, Canada.

Man goes to the temple

6 comentarios:

CardinalXiminez dijo...

Don't be that patriotic that soon: my favourite Canadian movie is Le Déclin de l'empire américain and THAT people seems to be very eager with dubious moral practices too. Things may have changed, who knows.

Now seriously: the sorrowful state of our tertiary education is definitely worth reviewing, but, who dares? The little single movement in the right direction is received by the deans mumbling against violation of the universitary autonomy and academic freedom; every proposal of change is received by the (poorly) politically charged students (which, bar rare exceptions, have become of the dog-whistle-and-flea-bearing, alcoholic-cum-anarchist type) as an conspirative attack by the international capitalism.

Anyway, the best and worst thing about this country (and I say this being a foreigner myself, remember) is that things change quickly. Forty years ago, college teachers kept little printed papers saying "I hereby certify that your recomendado (I can't translate it, sorry) passed the exam." (There is a copy in a Luis Carandell book.) Twenty years ago, in Granada, you probably couldn't be a vegetarian at all.

I believe that changing Spain is worth my talent. Is definitely more frustrating and more heartbreaking that making things that really helps mankind as a whole, things like the things you do. (And I'm being totally serious and non-ironic here.)

Who knows: maybe I can give my talent a better use, as everybody (and with that I means everybody) urges me to do. Maybe I'm just lazy. (That's probably true.)

I definitely understand you, but, please, never become totally frustrated with Spain. You never know where the redeeming surprise will be.

Anónimo dijo...

As always I think, Canadian, American, Scandinavian women should never leave their countries "cocoon"
and if they do, they should accept that the rules of the game are different everywhere.

Of course is better to be a man in Spain than in Canada.

laiabird dijo...

Ay, Luna, get them off their donkeys!

I was also more comfortable in academia in the U.S. than in Spain although thankfully I never lived anything at all like that. Really they treated me very well in Spain. My problems were more my own personal issues and also I felt there wasn't as much tradition or culture of research among students and, yes, some of the tenured professors.
There also wasn't the campus culture and debate/discussion I was used to among students.

On the other hand, and maybe becuase I am an outsider, there are so many things I love about Spain... so many things that I found more 'progressive' or richer in some way than in the U.S. (of course, I'm not comparing with Canada, which also offers things the US doesn't).
I agree with The Cardinal about the redeeming surprises :)
They'll come to you.
BTW although I think it's generally easier to be vegetarian here than in Spain, my favorite veg restaurant is in Madrid- Yerba Buena. Go figure :)

Lunatrix dijo...

Hey, thanks for your comments!! When I wrote this entry I was positive nobody was going to reply. In English and about problems with the university? Forget it!!

Let's see. I am not 100% convinced by the Canadian university system, or by the country. They both have a lot of problems, but they have given me more opportunities than Spain. The end of the entry is for better effect, I agree with Thiago.

I also agree with your friends that you have an amazing talent. Whether you want to use it for something ... useful?? is up to you though. I am sure whatever you do, it will be good. You really rock, dude, and I have no shame for not taking you out for lunch last saturday.

Guy without a name: is it really better to be a man in Spain? It bothers me to see racism and I am not black. Maybe it depends on how you define "better", for a sensitive person being in a position of privilege can be a hard thing.

Laia! For me it was the other way: I arrived "there" and thought, wow. People do talk in class!! And they are so articulate!! And profs listen to them!! That's definetely a big difference between the two systems.

I know that place. Have you been to El Granero de Lavapiés? That's the real deal!

I'll try not to lose hope with Spain. Promised :o)

Many hugs, L.

Anónimo dijo...

Like Laia, I generally didn't have problems with my profs in Spain, I was even a fan of a couple of them, but here in the US the vibe is so much different, profs are constantly asking for feedback from students, and students actually disagree with them in class in front of everybody. Wow! But the North American system is not perfect either, and the chair-warmer profs that are only interested in putting their name on expert papers exist here too. As Cardinal said, I'm sure you'll find redeeming surprises.

Anónimo dijo...
Este comentario ha sido eliminado por un administrador del blog.